Home  »  Afghanistan  »  Taliban Negotiating Release Of One Of Two Missing Naval Personnel After Killing The Other

Taliban Negotiating Release Of One Of Two Missing Naval Personnel After Killing The Other



Jul 25, 2010 12 Comments ›› Pat Dollard

captphoto_1279373646428-5-0

Los Angeles Times:

KABUL, Afghanistan — An insurgent faction that claimed to have killed one U.S. serviceman and captured another offered to exchange the slain man’s body for an unspecified number of prisoners, an Afghan official said Sunday.

The two missing Americans, identified by Western officials as U.S. Navy personnel, were last seen Friday in a dangerous part of Logar province, south of the Afghan capital. The NATO force has issued only terse statements regarding their disappearance, and said a massive air and ground search was under way.

Afghan officials in Logar have said the two, who were driving an armored sport-utility vehicle, may have taken a wrong turn and accidentally ended up in a Taliban-held area. NATO has not disclosed why the pair traveled to Logar after leaving their base in Kabul, or said whether the trip was authorized by their superiors.

Illustrating the sometimes splintered nature of the insurgency, there appeared to be confusion within the Taliban about which group had been involved in the confrontation. While the Taliban movement does have an overall command structure, local cells of insurgents _ sometimes intermingled with criminal gangs _ operate semi-autonomously in some parts of the country.

Word of the insurgents’ encounter with the Americans did not come directly from the Taliban’s usual spokesmen, but was relayed by Afghan authorities citing local intermediaries. The two Americans were reported to have disappeared in Charkh district, a hotbed of insurgent activity that is considered dangerous even for Afghan officials, let alone outsiders.

It would be highly unusual for U.S. service members to travel alone and virtually unprotected in the area, and Afghan officials depicted their presence as an apparently unexpected bonanza for the local Taliban.

“They moved toward an insecure area without informing the authorities, and there they encountered the enemy,” said Logar’s police chief, Gen. Mohammad Mustafa Mosseini. He said one of the Americans was killed and one taken alive after insurgents ambushed their vehicle with rocket-propelled grenades.

The insurgents’ demand for an exchange was disclosed by the head of the provincial council in Logar, Abdul Hakim Sulaimankhil. NATO said it has had no contact with the purported captors.

Western military officials on Sunday reported “offensive clearing operations” in Charkh overnight by Afghan and coalition troops that resulted in the capture of two suspected insurgents. The military did not say whether the raid yielded any information about the missing Navy men.

Although Afghanistan is landlocked, U.S. Navy personnel serve a variety of roles in combat here. They include medical corpsmen attached to units from various branches of service, bomb-disposal experts and also elite SEALS who are involved in special operations.

Until now, the Taliban’s only known American military prisoner has been Bowe Bergdahl, an Idaho native who was an Army private at the time of his capture 13 months ago in eastern Afghanistan. Last month he was promoted in absentia to Army specialist.

Bergdahl, whom American officials believe may have been taken across the frontier to Pakistan, has been seen in Taliban-made videos denouncing the Western troop presence.

The circumstances of his capture, too, were murky. In the immediate aftermath of his disappearance, U.S. military officials said he had apparently walked away from his base, but later backtracked on that assertion. In videos, Bergdahl has said he was seized after lagging behind on patrol.


  • Jane Wegener

    This is disgusting! Why are we having such a hard time in this country?? They have no planes, no tanks, no military equipment except guns and most of these people are illiterate. Not one of our soldiers is worth being lost in this country. Are we really fighting this war? What kind of rules of engagement do we have? I saw one report that they must NOT kill any civilians. Don’t our leaders realize this is WAR?

    • CPLViper

      Our leaders are limp dicks and should declare it a free fire zone, in my arrogant opinion. Screw winning hearts and minds … open fire, anyone one who survives inherits that land and will be grateful to just be breathing. Their hearts and minds will be won once we help them rebuild on the ashes (see Germany, Japan, France [sort of]). It is much easier to become friends with an ememy after you finish kicking the ever-loving shit out of them.

    • DocOne

      Viper is dead on. It was partly our Generals in the 101st calling for the “surge” after 2006 because we were getting hammered daily. The only problem is that our leaders were concerned with their next shiny pin, rank, not their soldiers or even the Iraqi civilians. I remember we took fire from an Iraqi police checkpoint once. We stopped it quick. Our team leader was called in by our LTC, he said did you take out that checkpoint? TL says abso-fucking-lutely. We took fire and neutralized the threat. LTC says was anyone hit, or just the vehicle. TL-No sir, no one was hurt. LTC- Then why did you return fire?

      Thats what we were dealing with across the board. It was disgusting

  • Tyler520

    trading a dead body for a dozen live prisoners?

    Fuck that – tell them to release the surviving soldier and the body, and we wont level an entire village at random with every citizen in it.

    Whatever happened to the good old days of ‘Scorched Earth’ policy?

    Fuck these neanderthals – it is time that they only exist in the history books

  • Guy

    I recall when Bush was in office, the news agencies would give a daily death toll in Iraq and Afghanistan. Well, this makes 258 US Servicemen so far this year. Ironic that the mass-media have stopped pounding the death-toll ritual since “The One” has been in office. As reported on the Wall Street Journal site: June was the deadliest month in the nine-year war, with 102 coalition casualties. This month, 75 coalition soldiers have been killed. The Disaster In Chief gets a pass for his inept leadership!

  • David

    Every American serviceman’s life is precious, but I want to know why they strayed form a position of relative safety to one of known danger. I like Tyler520′s suggestion.

  • http://www.killingjanefona.com C.L.Lucas

    These guys aren’t just ‘naval personnel’ they’re SEALS BTW-

    • CPLViper

      SEALS don’t get captured easily, they had to stumble into a hornet’s nest.

      My suggestion has always been to insert RFID chips that can only be activated with a unique code. When someone is missing, spark it up and get their exact GPS location (they can’t keep prisoners underground the entire time).

    • http://www.killingjanefona.com C.L.Lucas

      Oh, I know they don’t–given the unmarked/white SUV, they were prob. less armed then a normal team, perhaps mixed w/ other SF– who knows, it’s non-standard compared to the other SF stuff afoot–but I agree…Hornets nest.

    • IC

      I don’t care who they were; anyone should realize that driving in a single vehicle into enemy territory with only two people is STUPID and suicidal.

      Someone in the chain of command needs to face some serious NJP for this little adventure, including the captured knucklehead sailor/seal/whatever IF he manages to survive.

    • CPLViper

      I will withhold condemnation of everyone and anyone involved wuth the exception of the Taliban until more details are exposed, if they are exposed.

  • Bobby E.

    I’m sure O-Zero will secure a release as soon as he’s forked over half-a-billion dollars to the Palestinians.