Robert Gates Says Netanyahu Is “Ungrateful” Ally From Whom U.S. Has “Received Nothing In Return”

September 6th, 2011 (18) Posted By Pat Dollard.

GatesNetanyahu.jpg

Haaretz:

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is “ungrateful” toward the United States, former U.S. Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, who left his post in July of this year, claimed during a closed meeting with senior American government officials.

The news came to light after journalist Jeffery Goldberg reported in a blog post that the meeting took place a short time before Gates’ departure. According to the post, Gates listed off the steps that the U.S. government took to ensure Israel’s security, stating that the U.S. “received nothing” in return.

According to Goldberg, several senior government officials claim Gates told President Obama that not only is “Netanyahu ungrateful, but also endangering his country by refusing to grapple with Israel’s growing isolation and with the demographic challenges it faces if it keeps control of the West Bank.”

The former secretary of defense was also reported to have commented on a 2010 diplomatic incident, surrounding Israel’s approval of 1,600 new housing units in East Jerusalem during an official visit by U.S Vice President Joe Biden.

According to Goldberg’s report, Gates expressed great frustration at the incident, saying that if he had had been Biden he would have cut his Israel visit short as soon as the housing units were approved, adding that he would have told “the prime minister to call Obama when he was serious about negotiations.”

The report was not the first instance of an alleged mistrust of Netanyahu by global leaders. Earlier in the year former Downing Street communications chief Alistair Campbell indicated that former Prime Minister Tony Blair felt that the Israeli PM was untrustworthy. In the second volume of his diaries, wrote candidly of the British view of then, and current, Netanyahu, saying Foreign Office officials had nicknamed Netanyahu “the armor-plated bullter.”

Campbell goes on to say that this view was not held exclusively by U.K. officials, adding that former premier, and current Defense Minister Ehud Barak told Blair during a meeting that he was “was pessimistic because Bibi was a total bullter.”

Jihadi Killer Radio Hour
Follow Pat on Twitter
  • Jo

    if he is a ‘bullshiter” then gates, obam, and bi-dumb should have felt right at home.Oh, but you cant bullshit a bullshiter now can you

    • Anonymous

      Says the bullshitter to the Fox Snooze.

    • Anonymous

      Says the bullshitter to the Fox Snooze.

  • Mike_W

    What do you want, Obama, a share of God’s grace?
    The Jews are God’s chosen people and you and your ilk are pustules on Satan’s behind.

  • http://twitter.com/HolgerAwakens HolgerAwakens

    I’d like to point out that all of this came out in a “blogpost” by Jeffrey Goldberg.  Goldberg is a Lefty asswipe who writes for the Commie publication The Atlantic.  If you doubt me or wonder if Goldberg isn’t on a personal mission to smear Netanyahu, get the title of another article that Goldberg wrote on a similar subject: 


    Dear Mr. Netanyahu, Please Don’t Speak to My President That Way

    • Anonymous

      Who voted you as the new John Birch Society?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Robert-Bayer/687001618 Robert Bayer

    Robert Gates ..how about you give up your own home and land first?  What?! It wouldnt be fair?!  No kidding Stupid!

    • Anonymous

      If it was illegally occupied land, the law is on the side of the previous owners.

    • Anonymous

      If it was illegally occupied land, the law is on the side of the previous owners.

  • Charlie from New Jersey

    Oh, let’s see, is France grateful, is England, is Russia, is China? All of these countries would have been destroyed last century if not for the US. Are we whining about it? No! Why? Because nations do things in their own self interests and gratitude is an emotion that seldom applies to nations. Since we niw seem to be changing sides in the Middle East to more closely align with the radicals, Israel naturally acts differently toward us. Duh!
    … And Gates was the smartest one in the Obama Administration!

  • Charlie from New Jersey

    Oh, let’s see, is France grateful, is England, is Russia, is China? All of these countries would have been destroyed last century if not for the US. Are we whining about it? No! Why? Because nations do things in their own self interests and gratitude is an emotion that seldom applies to nations. Since we niw seem to be changing sides in the Middle East to more closely align with the radicals, Israel naturally acts differently toward us. Duh!
    … And Gates was the smartest one in the Obama Administration!

  • Charlie from New Jersey

    Oh, let’s see, is France grateful, is England, is Russia, is China? All of these countries would have been destroyed last century if not for the US. Are we whining about it? No! Why? Because nations do things in their own self interests and gratitude is an emotion that seldom applies to nations. Since we niw seem to be changing sides in the Middle East to more closely align with the radicals, Israel naturally acts differently toward us. Duh!
    … And Gates was the smartest one in the Obama Administration!

    • Anonymous

      You’re charging retribution from acts 50+ years ago????? How long should this retribution last? 1,000 years? Please.

  • Anonymous

    Mr Gates, just because you and the rest of the obambi wrecking crew refuse to act in America’s best interests, don’t expect other leaders, especially Bibi, to sacrifice their nation’s best interests and follow your lead. Bibi has to take responsibility for his nation’s survival, surrounded by lunatic hating demons, and act accordingly…  

  • Anonymous

    Mr Gates, just because you and the rest of the obambi wrecking crew refuse to act in America’s best interests, don’t expect other leaders, especially Bibi, to sacrifice their nation’s best interests and follow your lead. Bibi has to take responsibility for his nation’s survival, surrounded by lunatic hating demons, and act accordingly…  

  • Kemaste

    There is NOTHING to be gained by Israel if they give up more land for this elusive, ephemeral “peace.” They threw 9,000 Jews out of their home in Gaza ( One week later we had Katrina and 9,000 Americans lost their homes) after some had lived there 30 years with the encouragement and blessing of the Israeli government. They insisted peace would ensue but rockets rained down. Peace for those bastards means Israel must go along with the charade, act like they don’t know they are surrounded by rabid Muslims who want them destroyed. “Please die for the sake of peace” If Israel is destroyed do you really think there will be peace?

    http://www.mechon-mamre.org/p/pt/pt2683.htm

    • Anonymous

      The Israelis are colonizing occupied land, PERIOD. They displaced thousands of Palestinians from their lands for this plot of conquered and illegally occupied land.

  • Anagitator

    It is funny (not haha funny) that this report is not newsworthy enough for the USA MSM,  but that is to be expected when their primary role is one of propaganda and not news.

    BTW I agree that 10 years later it is time that we in the USA should have a candid public dialogue on the reasons we were attacked on 9-11,  and the strategic value or harm that results from our entangling relationship with Israel.