Oct 9, 2012 No Comments ›› Chuck Biscuits
No, the AP is not a Leftist propaganda organization…
Washington Post: Hmmm, what’s going on in this Mitt Romney photo from a campaign stop yesterday in Fairfield, Va.?
That’s what detractors want to know. Tim Graham of NewsBusters wrote last night of the Associated Press shot: “It’s unbelievable. It honestly looks like a little girl is gaping at Romney from behind.” And FoxNews.com gets expert Penn State expert Steve Manuel to say this about the image:
In this photo, while it may appear funny, AP knows exactly what viewers are thinking. It’s not legitimate news. AP knows that viewers are going to chuckle and imagine what the little girl is seeing, and it makes Gov. Romney appear a bit foolish.
The Associated Press has now come out with a statement on the photo controversy:
The Associated Press on Monday took and distributed six photos of Gov. Romney’s visit to an elementary school in Fairfield, Va., to its member news organizations and customers.
One image showed Mr. Romney as he was crouching down to pose for a photo with the schoolchildren. It received a caption addition on Tuesday to better explain what was happening. The caption addition was as follows:
CLARIFIES THAT STUDENT IS REACTING BECAUSE MITT ROMNEY WILL BE POSING FOR A PHOTO DIRECTLY IN FRONT OF HER AND HER CLASSMATES – Republican presidential candidate, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney poses for photographs with students of Fairfield Elementary School, Monday, Oct. 8, 2012, in Fairfield, Va. A student, right, reacts as she realizes Romney will crouch down directly in front of her and her classmates for the group photo. (AP Photo/Evan Vucci)
AP’s “caption addition” is helpful. Now we know what accounts for that amazed expression on the face of the child behind the Republican presidential candidate. Yet the statement here hews to the clinical, to its detriment. Why not a little statement of regret to the candidate for throwing out a photo that makes him look silly, sans explanation?
Excerpted from Fox News: It was a news photo that, as Gawker quipped, was “ripe for captioning.”
A pic of Mitt Romney bending over, while a seemingly astonished schoolgirl stands behind him, mouth agape.
The photograph, posted Monday by The Associated Press for all to see, has since surged across the Internet. The candidate riding a wave of confidence from last week’s debate performance was suddenly made, pardon, the butt of jokes.
So was it a cheap shot?
Tim Graham, media analysis director at the Media Research Center, said absolutely.
“It’s unbelievable,” he wrote. “It honestly looks like a little girl is gaping at Romney from behind.”
A closer look appears to show the girl looking at something else to the right of Romney. The caption, though, did not initially make clear what it is she’s staring at. The caption said: “Republican presidential candidate, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney poses for photographs with students of Fairfield Elementary School, Monday, Oct. 8, 2012, in Fairfield, Va.”
The AP has since tried to clarify. After FoxNews.com published an earlier version of this story questioning the use of the photo, the AP posted an updated caption to “better explain what was happening” — in that the girl was reacting because Romney was posing for a photo directly in front of her.
The updated caption read: “Republican presidential candidate, former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney poses for photographs with students of Fairfield Elementary School, Monday, Oct. 8, 2012, in Fairfield, Va. A student, right, reacts as she realizes Romney will crouch down directly in front of her and her classmates for the group photo.”
Steve Manuel, senior lecturer at Penn State’s College of Communications and an award-winning photojournalist, said the AP must have known how the image would be perceived when they published it.
“In this photo, while it may appear funny, AP knows exactly what viewers are thinking,” he wrote in an email. “It’s not legitimate news. AP knows that viewers are going to chuckle and imagine what the little girl is seeing, and it makes Gov. Romney appear a bit foolish. That isn’t the purpose or mission of photojournalism. … Candidate or not, it is not the mission of a news organization to place anyone in a position to be ridiculed or made fun of. Reporting the news is, and this is not newsworthy.”
Stephen Ward, director of the Center for Journalism Ethics at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, said the photo by itself was not too offensive but noted it could be exploited.
“Looking at the photo, it just strikes me as not particularly offensive. It’s more funny,” he said. “But in a highly charged political environment like this, you have to be very careful. I don’t particularly have a problem with the shot. As long as the caption is fine. My problem is in how people might use it.”
The AP may have entered a bit of a gray area with this one. The photo was not altered or manipulated in any apparent way. But the National Press Photographers Association code of ethics offers some guidance.
“Treat all subjects with respect and dignity,” it says. The code also says: “Be complete and provide context when photographing or recording subjects.”
Graham noted that the image coincided with a story with a decidedly anti-Romney tone.
The AP piece that ran around the same time was about how Romney had decided to skip a Nickelodeon-sponsored “Kids Pick the President” special that President Obama had agreed to.
The story was in large part a venue for show producer Linda Ellerbee to sound off on the Republican nominee.
“That’s several million kids who actually want to get involved in the democratic process,” Ellerbee told the AP. “They don’t deserve to be dissed. But former Gov. Romney also blew off Letterman and Big Bird, so I guess we’re in good company.”
Romney’s campaign claimed it didn’t have time. Also, kids don’t actually vote.